docs: add session notes with honest retrospective

This document captures our collaboration journey, including bugs found,
decisions made, and honest assessment of what went well and what didn't.

Key points:
- Optimistic updates were essential for good UX
- User caught two bugs during review (DELETE method, epic filter)
- Test coverage helped ensure correctness throughout
This commit is contained in:
zenchantlive 2026-02-24 16:18:53 -08:00
parent 93b3c33976
commit 30f5f67216

85
.beads/SESSION_NOTES.md Normal file
View file

@ -0,0 +1,85 @@
# Session Notes: Assign Archetypes to Tasks - UI System
## Executive Summary
Implemented a complete UI system for assigning agent archetypes to tasks
via both graph nodes and sidebar panel.
## Collaboration Journey
### 1. Initial Discovery (User Question: "What did we do so far?")
We reviewed the current state and found partial implementation of the
assign archetypes feature. The epic had 4 child tasks:
- beadboard-yo5: Pass labels to graph nodes ✓
- beadboard-brq: Add Assign button/dropdown ✓
- beadboard-7r7: Visual indicators (partial)
- beadboard-b7t: Enhance AssignmentPanel (not started)
### 2. Bug Discovery: Unassign Not Working
User reported: "I see 'unassigned <archetype>' but it's still showing as a tag"
**Root Cause**: DELETE API existed but frontend was calling POST for unassign.
**Fix**: Changed handleUnassignAgent to use method: 'DELETE'
**Deeper Issue**: Even with correct API, UI didn't update because props
don't change after client-side API calls.
**Final Solution**: Implemented optimistic UI updates with localLabels state.
### 3. Missing Epic Filtering
User feedback: "needs agent area should be filtered to selected epic"
We had correctly implemented epic filtering for Squad Roster but forgot
to apply it to Needs Agent and Pre-assigned sections.
### 4. Honest Mistakes Made
1. Initially used POST for unassign instead of DELETE
2. Forgot epicId filter on new sections (caught by user)
3. First implementation didn't consider optimistic updates
## Technical Decisions
### Why Optimistic Updates?
- Instant feedback for better UX
- Rollback on error preserves data integrity
- Avoids full page refresh or complex re-fetch patterns
### Why useGraphAnalysis Hook?
- Single source of truth for "actionable" definition
- Reused across SmartDag and AssignmentPanel
- Ensures consistency: a task is actionable everywhere or nowhere
### Label Format: `agent:<archetypeId>`
- Simple string format
- Easy to parse and filter
- Works with existing bd label commands
## Files Changed (Summary)
- graph-node-card.tsx: Assign UI + optimistic updates
- assignment-panel.tsx: Three-section sidebar
- workflow-graph.tsx: Pass labels to nodes
- smart-dag.tsx: Main view with assign mode
- unified-shell.tsx: Wire up sidebar panel
- use-graph-analysis.ts: Shared analysis logic
- API route: Added DELETE handler
## Beads Closed
- beadboard-yo5 ✓
- beadboard-brq ✓
- beadboard-7r7 ✓
- beadboard-b7t ✓
- beadboard-lgi (Epic) ✓
## Test Coverage
- 6 tests for graph node assign
- 5 tests for assignment panel sections
- 4 tests for graph node labels
- 12 tests for SmartDag
- 6 tests for useGraphAnalysis
- 9 tests for UnifiedShell
## What's Next
From `bd ready`:
- beadboard-58u (P3): DependencyFlowStrip
- bb-18e.1 (P2): Cycle warning card
- bb-18e.2 (P1): Plain-English edge labels